$1.99 Trails iPhone App More Acccurate Than $200 Garmin Edge 305

by Justin on December 8, 2008

iphone vs garmin $1.99 Trails iPhone App More Acccurate Than $200 Garmin Edge 305

In another deathblow to the portable navigation device industry, a third party review has found the Trails iPhone application more accurate than the Garmin Edge 305.  The application, developed by German Felix Lamouroux, allows you to import, export and store GPX file format information if you happen to be a hiker, backpacker, jogger, etc.  You can also geotag and geocode non-iPhone pictures and share your travels with others on Google Earth.

The real story here is that the accuracy of the Trails app is more accurate than the positioning information acquired by the Garmin Edge 305.  That’s a big surprise.  From ZDnet.com:

For example, if you look where the green arrow is pointing in the first image in the article, the Edge futzes by 15 meters the positions when the bike was parked.  Same difference with the second photo showing the part of the trip in the forest.

In the second picture one can see both devices with clear view to the sky providing possibly equal results. As soon as it goes, however, into the woods, the exactness of the Edge strongly decreases. [My editing of a machine translation (advised by my high school German classes).]

You can download the Trail iPhone app at the app store.  Give it a try and let me know what you think.

  • Peter Piper
    So what you're saying is the £750GBP iPhone is more accurate than the £150 Edge 205?

    NO SHIT SHERLOCK!!!!

    Of course, what would be interesting is if you compared it with a £375 GPS tracking device. I'd expect that to perform at least as well, because Apple is notorious for charging twice as much as it's competitors for the same technology.
  • bananaboy
    If a smartphone's integrated GPS even remotely compares to the capabilities of a 375GBP dedicated GPS tracking device, I don't think anyone in their right mind would complain about the maker "charging twice as much as it's competitors for the same technology".

    Elementary, my dear Watson.
  • bananaboy
    .
  • Thanks for the tip! I'll definitely check it out.
  • GeoLogTag
    I made an iPhone app called GeoLogTag that you can use as a geologger AND a geotagger. GeoLogTag gives you the possibility to geotag photos taken with any digital camera! On top of that it integrates nicely with Flickr.

    More info on how GeoLogTag works can be found here.

    You can find GeoLogTag in the App Store here.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: