Yelp accused of blackmail, extortion, compared to the Mafia

by Justin on February 19, 2009

 Yelp accused of blackmail, extortion, compared to the MafiaYelp, a user-generated business review website based in San Francisco, has been the topic of many a news story recently related to negative business review postings.  And the occasional lawsuit that follows.  But things definitely got much worse for the becoming-infamous startup due to a long, long article in the East Bay Express today.  The article’s title?  Yelp and the Business of Extortion 2.0.  Ouch.

Numerous business owners who have profiles on Yelp have accused the company of using shady business practices in order to make money.  Frequent sales calls from the company offering to remove negative reviews for $299 a month are apparently a big revenue driver.  Some business owners have stated that negative reviews mysteriously move to the top of their profiles before the business calls, or negative reviews appear if the offer is denied.  Many think these negative reviews are written by Yelp employees in order to generate sales leads.

In fact, most of the business owners who came forward with allegations wouldn’t even give their real names fearing retaliation from the company.  Obviously a website with 16 million unique visitors monthly has quite the power over mom-and-pop shops.  Hence the Mafia comparison in the title of this article.

I’ll let you read the six page article yourself for all the details, but the theme of the article doesn’t differ from page one on.  Many a business owner feels Yelp is crooked.  Yelp’s response?  Denial, denial, denial.  If this kind of publicity keeps up for the company, expect a business with great potential to bite the dust.

Read

 Yelp accused of blackmail, extortion, compared to the Mafia
  • Yashi
    Not a business owner but find Yelp creepy-nasty just the same. My good reviews are always dropped from one particular business. I even created another account and added a new review, but it dropped down the same black hole. Other people trying to post good reviews for the same business find their opinions disappear just as quickly, leaving just three very negative reviews from people who seem to specialize in vitriol. Worst part? No one to ask why this keeps happening. No link. No information. Just more disappearing reviews.

    This business has been around for over thirty years and they're now losing business because of this very shady, online assassination. All I can do now is not visit the site. I have absolutely no faith in what's posted there.
  • AdamJohnson09
    Yelp is very shady site, my company had 12 positive reviews and one bad review and then one day it was down to four. Of course, the one bad review was the first one listed at the top of the page. Magically, the NEXT DAY a yelp ad rep called me pushing me to sign up for their paid advertising program. I declined and over the next few weeks we were back up to about 12 positive reviews. Like clockwork, all the recent review were erased except the one bad review. The phone rings and again its a yelp rep trying to get me to sign up to advertise. When I question the supposedly "automatic" removal of the reviews he become very vague and implies that if I spend money to advertise that it shouldn't happen. The entire thing just seems VERY shady and borderline illegal. They are almost blackmailing people into paying to maintain their online reputation.
  • Bill
    They called my hotel once and got me (at the Front Desk). When I told them the General Manager is not available to speak with them, the woman on the phone said, "Please let her know we'd like to talk with her about the reviews of your hotel on Yelp," or something very similar to that. It felt like a threat (or a shakedown).
  • Charles
    True story. I know the owner of a highly successful, highly popular, generations-old restaurant who was contacted by Yelp and pitched with their protection racket of removing negative reviews in exchange for a monthly fee. This is as crooked as it comes.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: